DATE: Tue, 07 Dec 1993 02:38:16 CDT From: Winslow Yerxa <76450.32~ompuServe.COM> Subject: Practice, Practice
How do you get to Carnegie Hall?
Practice.
I suspect that most really good players practice as much as they can. Whenever I'm with Toots, he's always noodling to himself, playing along with the car radio, whatever. Hendrik Meurkens tells me he doesn't feel like he can play if he doesn't practice for at least two hours. Then he feels warmed up, and feels like he has some tone. Howard Levy is another guy who's always playing. Our interviews are filled with little musical illustrations - far too many to transcribe, although it would be nice to publish them.
Fun is a big part of it, and the joy and reward of achieving something. Setting a short term goal is important, becuase it's easy to measure progress. Long term goals, even very minute ones, are important, too. For 20 years I tried to bend Draw 2 down two semitones on a #365 Marine Band in C (the one that's tuned an octave lower). I concluded it was an unlikely pursuit, but I would try anyway. Then one day Steve Baker showed me that it was possible - he could do it. A couple of weeks later, much to my surprise, I had it! After a totally fruitless pursuit - I mean no results. Then, suddenly, boom!
I have awful practice habits - mostly I noodle with some purpose in mind - finding a way through a particular chord, or working on some bend or overblow - but when I'm doing things right, I like to spend about an hour playing scales with a metronome. This really gets your breathing and tone going, and if you pay attention and try to lock in with the metronome, it can do wonders for your time. Plus the hypnotic aspect is relaxing and makes me a little more receptive. Always start with a comofrtable tempo, especially for new exercises. You'l always play it better and with greater assurance at a fast tempo if you can first play it slowly.
Once I've done that, I want to bust out, so I'll play along with some Aebersold chord progression records, improvising. I find I'm much more fluent and inventive, and have quicker responses and better intuition if I'm warmed up. If I run into difficulty with a particular progression (especially a new one), I'll devise some kind of scale or lick exercise to find a way to "navigate" through it on the instrument, and to hear my way through it on a tonal level. I may sit down at the piano and play through the progression to help with this process.
If I try to run through too much material, especially stuff that isn't well within my comfort zone, I start to fatigue mentally, so then I'll go on to some repertoire work, again playing along with "music minus one"-type tracks that contain material inside the zone. Sometimes I'll switch instruments and work on something else - go between diatonic, chromatic, and bass in some combination, just for a change. Or do something unrelated for awhile, then come back to it.
I may also play along with records - not the playalong kind. This is sort of creepy - the other musicians don't know you're there, and you have to watch that you don't blunt you musical sensitivity by imposing yourself on something that can't respond, but if you're careful, you can learn things about fitting into unfamiliar situations. However, it can help you gauge how much you can fit in stylistically with what's going on. Plus, you can get inspiration and insight by being close to the sounds of good players.
Playing along with live musicians instead of tapes or computers is always preferable, becuase they're always more challenging, even the bad ones - especially the bad ones. You don;t hear the same thing over and over, and you gain exposure to different styles, energy levels and idiosyncracies, and learn to interact.
Ultimately, the best thing to do is go out and gig. I've been away from regular gigging for a few years, and it shows. When I'm onstage, instead of thinking about how to give the music to the audience through expression and creative interaction with the other musicians, I'm worrying about balance, pacing, intensity, stamina and ideas. Not a pleasant sensation. Gigging is the true test. If you can do it in front of an audience of strangers, in an environment far more vulnerable and less subject to your control than the proverbial woodshed, you can do it anywhere.
I once gave a guy several pages of written-out scales, and he gave me a look, and said - "How can you bring yourself to do all this?" I told him I relished it - which was true. You'll dig a deep hole if you know there's gold buried, and you may even enjoy the act of digging if you enjoy the texture and aroma of the soil and the feel of your body thrusting and swinging the shovel, the sound and feel of the steel blade as it bites into the soil. If you really *listen* to yourself, and work with what you hear, you'll be amazed at the improvements you can make.
Three valuable things I've learned about stumbling blocks:
Break a difficult task down into the smallest possible segments, and work on the part that's hanging you up. If several things are giving you trouble, isolate each one in turn. When you've got a better feel for it, put it back in its larger context. If it still gives you trouble, maybe there's some other contributing factor in that context that you need to identify and isolate, or maybe you've trained yourself through repetition to make that mistake in that context, in which case you need to untrain yourself by doing something different and then coming back to it.
Sometimes you just need to give something some air. Go away from it for awhile. When you come back, you may find that the situation has "settled" and that there is an improvement. Sometimes practice needs time to sink in.
In longer event chains, like scales or other linear exercises, sometimes mistakes in playing are due to mistaken identity - you're trying to do one thing, but your nervous system is substituting something familiar that happens to resemble in some way the thing you're trying to do. I notice this especially with scales on the chromatic - for instance, segments of the Eb Major scale play indentically to the C scale on the same scale degrees, but then, of course, they diverge. If you can identify the source of this substitution (where is the mistake leading you?), and keep the differences in mind, this can help eliminate the problem.