From: Jerry Date: Sat, 31 Aug 1996 03:15:35 -0400 Subject: Tounging Vs. Puckering
I'm really enjoying the debate back and forth. Everyone ( well, almost everyone ) is scoring some good points. With so many obviously knowledgable players out there, I'll limit my guru info advice for teachers. If you have a class full of kids, take the advice of the over 3,000 Middle School students I have instructed in harp. Are you sitting on the edge of your seats??? O.K. They won't do well with tounging IN THE FIRST YEAR because it's too messy. It's that simple. I developed the straw method ( in detail in my book for classroom instruction ) and kids make that work. Later on, they will need to switch over to a more sophisticated method, but for that first year.......... let's first get them hooked on the harmonica, then they will want to play more musical ideas, and ask for more methods to do this.....enter tounging. I'll give you more help or details if you e-mail me. Always wishing my fellow players the best, J E R R Y