From: Michael Will Date: Wed, 25 Sep 1996 08:10:25 -0700 Subject: Re: Gary P's thumb
> This divide between Diatonic and Chromatic still has a psychological > barrier for some people...don't see it myself. Is it the fact that one has > valves and 'tother hasn't??? If it is then it is a silly barrier, > different characteristics for different aspects of playing (Brass players > have a similar sort of divide.
I think the valves are indeed part of it. I removed the windsavers from the D and A draw reeds on my CX-12 and those holes play and bend like a diatonic--both reeds participate.
I think cupping is another issue. You just can't get your hands around a chromatic. And mostly they won't fit in your pocket.
And to Play the chromatic Harmonica Well you might need some icky music theory.