From: "William R. Epping" <104124.33~ompuServe.COM> Date: 18 Oct 96 15:06:11 EDT Subject: Re: Reed Valves
Regarding reed valves:
The lower layer of the Hohner plastic windsaver valve is flexible and coated with talc on the side facing the reedplate, to help prevent sticking. The upper layer is stiffer, to keep the valve from opening too far. If the valve should open too far it would take longer to close, thus affecting response, and could also cause excess noise. The top layer is shorter than the thinner, bottom layer, allowing the tip of the thin layer to open and the reed to play at low volume. The cup valves used on the lowest reeds of the 4-octave models are designed to accomodate the deep swing of these heavy reeds. Cup valves are used on the outside only as there is insufficient room for them on the inside of a reed cell. Fortunately, inside valves generally cause less trouble than outside valves.
A while back I mentioned that we were testing plastic valves with a surface roughened by sandpaper, designed to prevent sticking. Sorry to say they were too noisy and didn't help with the sticking. Leather, the original valve material, is not without its own merits. When supple and properly adjusted it is very quiet, and will not become stuck to the reedplate by moisture or sediment, though it can get stiff and noisy if wetted too much. Less reflective on its surface than plastic, leather imparts a softer, warmer tone than plastic windsavers. This may be seen as an advantage or disadvantage, depending on one's preference. Leather valves, by the way, should only be applied to reedplates with shellac. Any other glue will clog the nap, making any later re-curling and re-setting difficult. Dry shellac, on the other hand, will turn to powder when scraped, leaving the nap undamaged.