What the book says about it is this: "The ability to bend all of the noes listed may take the average player as long as several years, and although the 4e, 5e, and 6e notes can be bent, they are so difficult and rarely used in playing that they have been left out of this book. They are probably used by fewer than one in 10,000 players."
I'm not sure what you mean when you say "Usually you can bend the higher note in the same numbered hole"?. Haven't yet been able to bend the 5i to save my life. The 8b is the first bend I figured out, and the tongue motion is almost identical to the 8d. The 8 hole seems to be the easiest for me to do, and the one which gets the best and most consistent tone . The 10 is the toughest single blow bend for me, I don't hit it with much consistency at all right now. More often it will pop down just a wee bit sharp of the whole step blow draw, and when I'm trying for the whole step, I have to aim the tip of my tongue just a little bit lower than where it sems to want to go, and I think flatten or cup behind the tip of my tongue a little bit. I'm also, as I said *very* surprised that I stumbled into what I have only seen described as a very advanced technique so early. Guess it helps to be obsessive-compulsive......
The 9 one-step blow bend is *really* loud if I use the same pressure as the straight 9. The way I stumbled upon it, and the reason I was putting so much effort into it, is that I thought it would sound really cool to do a slide in the chorus of the song I asked the list about (no, it's not Roll Out the Barrels, it's the one with all the yodeling in the chorus) , which goes like this:
What I kind of have in mind, in my mind's ear, is a legato slide that would be similar to the sound of a guitarist bending the string up a whole step before striking the note, and then releasing the bend smoothly after picking the string. What I do get is a lot more abrupt than that; the tip of my tongue seems to want to snap into place as if being drawn into a vacuum rather than to slide smoothly from the natural draw note to the whole-step draw bend.
Yes, the harmonica lends itself well to this and similar styles. I like playing descending two-note runs, alternating blowing and drawing as I descend (or ascent, or go back and forth). Sounds really nice, and it's very easy to do.
Anyway, Mr. OCD is staying up way to late and is going to sleep through his off-day if he doesn't shut up. Thanks for any and all.
Matt
Also sprach Hans:
> The book gives a layout of what bends are available for each blow and draw > for every hole. Specifically, it says you can so single (half-step) bends > in the upper register for 8 and 9 blows, and 5, 6, and 10 draws, and a > double (whole-step) draw on 10.
This doesn't seem right. Usually you can bend the higher note in the same numbered hole. This would give draw bends on 1-6 and blow bends on 7-10. The blow bends on 7-10 are trickier. I think it unlikely that a beginner would be able to blow bend 10 on a C harp though!
The song sounds a bit like roll out the barrel? Which goes back to the layout of the harmonica. If you block the lower three notes with your tongue and play melody on the top note you can add chords by moving your tongue. This works particularly well for polka's. You can also block 2,3 and play an octave on 1,4 then chord by opening up 2,3. It is likely harmonica's were originally designed to enable playing with polka bands. It seems like I recall the Hohner pampflets warning against bending notes!